FA Cup: What happened inside DW Stadium when Man City lost to Wigan

To some extend – the Tics had a strong push in the game-changing decision. They harassed the ref into a decision while crowding him.

You could see the ref sweating in those few moments. Questioned asked promptly, was it a red or not?

In my opinion, and spreading no negativity about bad decisions made, diving, or anything degrading to the game (I’ve been accused of doing this, and being a car-park jockey. So just taking the time out to clear the air).

I’m split about this dispute. I’ve seen players sent for less, and this once again displays the inconsistency, of the people taking charge of important matches.

Why I say it shouldn’t have been a red

The ref was on the verge of issuing a yellow card, with no intention on changing his assessment.

Having no discussion with anybody else – he changed his mind within seconds, and gave Delph his marching orders. Players involvement, and so-called, assistance from the fourth official was the influence in the change of heart.

He was caught in two minds, if you unsure about the decision, you cannot give Red, is that not ruling?

Why I say it should have been red

The Englishman was in no control of the slide, and put the next player in danger. Yes, the game is a contact sport – but sliding so recklessly, was bad enough for him to slide into the dressing room as he did.

The second reason for this is, other situations of less contact, gets awarded. That, plus other decisions where Pep was the one who profited from bad decision-making, by the referees, or linesman – is why I say it should have been red.

This gives me the 50/50 split on the problem that sparked FA Cup drama.